Best Grill Mats
If you enjoy grilling, you’ve probably been trying to figure out how to cook without causing a cleanup problem. The product you’re looking for is a grill mat. It’s an accessory that makes your life much easier. Anyway, it’s easier to scrub the grill mat in the sink than to clean the greasy grates. Now that you’re here, we’ll help you choose the grill mat that meets all your requirements. Take a look at our top picks.
Top 5 Grill Mats
In the following reviews, we give you the good and bad sides of the best grill mats, as well as those of the best under grill mat on the market, which will help you keep your grill and floor mess and damage-free. And finally, make sure to check the things you should consider before you lay your hands on one.
Best Grill Mat Overall – Kitchen + Home Review
When you’re looking for a heavy-duty grill mat, I won’t say you should stop here, but you’re getting pretty close. This versatile product will spare you hours of cleaning after cooking. It’s not designed for grills only, but gas, electric, microwave, and toaster ovens as well.
|Thick and sturdy||Some question its durability|
|Washable and reusable|
The Kitchen + Home grill mat is thick and sturdy, therefore heat-resistant. It can handle even up to 500°F. But still, not thick enough to handle direct flame, so make sure never to put it over one. If it’s too large or the shape doesn’t fit your grill or oven, you can trim it slightly with scissors.
The grill mat comes with a smooth surface, which prevents the food from sticking. Furthermore, it’s reusable. Just rinse it in the dishwasher after every use, and it’s ready to use once again. It won’t compromise the taste of your food as well. What’s more, you shouldn’t have any safety concerns using the grill mat since it’s FDA approved. In other words, it’s made of materials that don’t release chemicals or smoke.
But, nothing’s perfect, so neither is the Kitchen + Home grill mat. As some report, it burnt or even melted shortly after they got it. However, four pieces come with the package, so if some damages, you can replace it anytime.
All in all, the Kitchen + Home grill mats come with everything you need to minimize the time you spend on cleaning your cooking appliance. Also, considering their performance, you’ll get a good value for money. Highly recommended!
Yoshi Copper Grill Mat Review
Yoshi Copper grill mat will keep foods from falling into the grill, so you enjoy the cooking even more. Being heat-resistant, it can be placed directly on the grill or oven rack to protect the food from sticking or falling through the grates. It is infused with copper and has a nonstick PTFE-coated glass fabric sheet, which doesn’t contain PFOA, making the grill mat perfectly safe to use. What’s more, it retains the heat evenly and imparts grilled flavor as well as grill marks.
|BPA-free||Doesn’t work quite well with greasy foods|
|Heats quickly and evenly||Might not be that easy to clean|
Speaking of maintenance, make sure to rinse it after every use, or simply put it in the dishwasher, so you can use it time and again. Although, as some report, you might have some difficulties while doing so. However, it’s surely easier than cleaning the whole grill. When it comes to size, regardless of its dimensions, you can cut the mat to fit any area.
On the other hand, there’ve been a few cases where the grill mat happened to burn while cooking greasy food. Therefore, you better avoid using it on foods that throw off grease, which once accumulated on the mat surface, can become a fire hazard.
Overall, the Yoshi Copper grill mat performs rather well and lets you keep your grill and oven clean. On top of that, the package comes with two grill mats, so it’s absolutely worth the money.
Copper Chef Grill and Bake Mats Review
If you go for the Copper Chef grill and bake mats, you’ll get a package of 4 pieces – two small and two large ones. But still, if neither of them fits your oven or grill, you can cut them with a pair of scissors.
|PFOA and PTFE-free||Not very thick|
|Tolerates up to 500°F||Flimsy|
|Reusable and Dishwasher-safe|
The Copper Chef grill and bake mats are copper mesh and don’t contain PTFE, therefore non-toxic. They’re nonstick, heat easily and quickly, and apparently can handle up to 500°F. But, they appear to be paper-thin actually, because of which burn holes might appear after grilling. Additionally, they don’t leave grill marks as supposed to, which should be the least of your concerns.
When maintained properly, the grill mat should last longer. Therefore, clean it after every use, either in the dishwasher or rinse with water, soap, and nonmetal scrubber.
On the other hand, it might become a potential fire hazard when you use it on greasier foods seeing that the accumulated grease causes flare-ups.
Compared to the grill mats we reviewed before, the Copper Chef grill and bake mats are far from the best. After all, the only thing that resembles how advertised is that the food doesn’t fall through.
Grillaholics Grill Mat Review
The Grillaholics is a set of two heavy-duty grill mats that will keep your foods on the grates and make your grilling experience more enjoyable.
|Non-toxic||Some found it difficult to clean it|
|Capable of withstanding up to 500°F|
|Washable and reusable|
It comes with PTFE nonstick coating, and you can use both sides of the mat into the bargain. The grill mat is FDA-approved, which means it doesn’t contain any chemicals, and hence safe to use. It’s also capable of withstanding up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. However, make sure you don’t expose it at higher temperatures since it’ll deteriorate. Don’t place it too close to open flame or coals as well to prevent from burning holes. But then again, the grease will accumulate on the surface, which can be a reason for flare-ups.
Furthermore, the Grillaholics grill mat is very easy to clean since all you have to do is put it in the dishwasher after each use. Or scrub and rinse it instead. Although, some had difficulties while doing so. Either way, wait for the mat to cool first. After cleaning, you can use it over and over again. Moreover, if you find the grill mat too large for your cooking surface, it’s thin enough to trim it easily to any size with scissors. Also, use soft grill tools on it, like plastic or silicone, so you don’t damage it. Lastly, it’s covered by a lifetime warranty.
Seeing that you get two mats for the price, you’ll get your money’s worth. It doesn’t come with any additional features or differs in any way from the rest of the mats on our list, but still, does a decent job.
Kona Grill Mat Review
Kona grill mat is so far the thickest and with the highest heat tolerance – that is, 600°F. As we’ve already seen, most of the competitive models can handle only up to 500°F. Also, you’re safe from chemicals as it’s PFOA-free. The mat works with all grill types and ovens. But, when grilling on a charcoal grill, you better not cook greasy foods to avoid flare-ups. Also, never place it directly on the flames. On the other hand, it might take longer for the mat to heat because of its thickness. Therefore, you can preheat it before cooking.
|Heat tolerance - up to 600°F||Doesn’t work best with greasy foods|
|PFOA-free||Might take a bit longer to heat|
The Kona grill mat is nonstick, and thus very easy to clean. After each use, put it in the dishwasher or hand wash with soapy water and nonmetal scrubber or brush. This way, you can use it many times over. If the mat doesn’t fit the cooking surface, cut it. Never overlap the two mats though, they might stick together. Moreover, the product is covered by a 7-year warranty to ensure your peace of mind.
On the whole, the Kona grill mat works perfectly. The food flavor will remain uncompromised, while the cooking mess will stay on the mat. Even though it comes at a higher price, this set of 2 grill mats is worth the money.
Under Grill Mat – Great for Patios!
By now, you’ve probably found the perfect mat to keep your grill free of mess. But, how to protect the floor from damage caused by spills and drips around the grill? With a heavy-duty under grill mat, of course. That’s when the GrillTex under the grill mat comes to the rescue.
GrillTex Under the Grill Mat Review
To fit the grill best, the mat should be at least 2 to 3 inches larger than the perimeter of the grill. Therefore, given that it’s 36” by 63”, GrillTex under the grill mat will fit almost any grill and smoker. If it’s too small, however, the same model comes in a larger size as well.
|Tolerates 500°F||Not recommended for composite decks|
|Contains anti-fungal agents|
|1-year limited warranty|
Being made of recycled synthetic rubber, it won’t stain the underneath surface. Also, it won’t soak up all the rainwater when left outside. It contains anti-fungal agents as well, which prevent the under grill mat from decaying. Moreover, collecting any grease and drips that come from the grill, it keeps your floor stainless and clean. In terms of temperature, it can take up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. However, keep it away from the sun since it can get too hot.
On the other hand, the GrillTex under the grill mat doesn’t work best with composite decks, since it happens to discolor the deck boards. While we’re at maintenance, it’s nothing different than that of grill mats. All it takes is to rinse it with soap and warm water. Finally, it comes with a 1-year limited warranty in case it’s damaged.
All things considered, besides a grill mat, you need a heavy-duty, top quality under grill mat as well to enjoy your grilling sessions completely. Luckily, that’s exactly what the GrillTex under the grill mat is.
Grill Mats Buying Guide
When buying a grill mat, you can’t just take the first product that will catch your eye. Since all of them come with different dimensions, materials, features, and prices, you should pay attention to some factors to find the one that fits your needs and budget best.
Additional Features – Non-Sticky Mats
When to Use Grill Mats?
You can use a grill mat on almost any occasion, regardless of whether you’re cooking on grill, oven, or stove. It’ll keep even the tiniest foods on the grilling surface, the grates grease-free, and you won’t bother to clean a mess later. However, you should always keep in mind that grilling greasy foods will most likely cause flare-ups, which might become a potential fire hazard.
Taking care of your grill mat is a thing, but you should also clean your BBQ grill as often as possible, ideally after every use.
Best Grill Mats FAQs
As the name implies, the grill mats are designed for grilling. Therefore, they will work with any type of grill, provided that they’re not exposed to heat beyond their maximum temperature capacity and they don’t come into direct contact with the flames.
Non-stick grill mats are reusable and washable, therefore as long as you follow the temperature guidelines and maintain them properly, you can use them over and over. Place the grill mat on the grates any time you grill, wash it afterward, then use it all over again.
Grill mats are made of fiberglass cloth coated with PTFE, which is inert – that is, chemically inactive, and used to coat nonstick cookware. Both materials are safe to use as long as the product is FDA-approved. You’ll come across grill mats with PFOA-free labels as well. Speaking of which, PFOA is a chemical, which is found to increase the risk of cancer, and was used to make PTFE. But, since 2013, it’s phased out of use.